The Evolution of SEO: How to Rank in an Agentic AI World

Nate Nead
May 12, 2025

Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has always been about one thing: visibility.

From the early days of keyword stuffing and backlink farming to the era of semantic search and Core Web Vitals, the goal has remained the same—get found by users looking for answers.

But what happens when those “users” are no longer human?

Enter Agentic AI—a new generation of autonomous AI agents capable of making decisions, taking actions, and even conducting web research on behalf of human users.

These AI agents don’t just search—they execute tasks, compare data, and select the best outcomes with little or no human intervention.

And their rise is fundamentally changing the rules of SEO.

How is SEO is evolving in the age of Agentic AI?

What does Agentic AI mean for digital marketers and website owners?

How to future-proof your content strategy for a world where algorithms don’t just rank content—they consume and act on it.

The Evolution of SEO

To understand where SEO is headed, it’s helpful to look back at where it’s been.

Over the past two decades, SEO has evolved through several major phases—each driven by changes in user behavior and search engine technology.

1. The Early Web: Keywords and Backlinks
In the early 2000s, SEO was relatively primitive. Rankings were heavily influenced by keyword density, exact match domains, and the quantity of inbound links. The system was easily gamed, and websites often prioritized search engines over user experience.

2. The Google Revolution: Smarter Algorithms
Google changed the game with algorithm updates like:

Panda (2011), targeting thin or low-quality content
Penguin (2012), penalizing link schemes
Hummingbird (2013), improving understanding of search intent

These updates shifted SEO toward content quality, relevance, and semantic search, forcing marketers to focus more on value than tricks.

3. Mobile-First and User Experience
With the rise of mobile, Google introduced mobile-first indexing, placing greater emphasis on responsive design and page speed. This era also brought Core Web Vitals, metrics that measure real-world user experience.

4. The AI Era: RankBrain and BERT
Google began integrating machine learning with updates like RankBrain and BERT, enabling it to better understand natural language and context. This marked the beginning of AI-assisted search—and the first real steps toward AI being more than a ranking assistant.

Now, we’re entering a new phase.

Agentic AI is changing how people interact with the internet altogether—and SEO must evolve once again.

Enter Agentic AI in SEO

Agentic AI refers to artificial intelligence systems that are not just reactive but proactive—capable of taking initiative, making autonomous decisions, and pursuing specific goals on behalf of users.

Unlike conventional AI, which answers questions or performs simple tasks when prompted, agentic systems operate with a higher degree of independence.

A few examples might include:

AutoGPT and BabyAGI: autonomous agents that can execute multi-step tasks, even done without a specific prompt, but with a specific outcome in mind.
Personal AI assistants: capable of booking travel, shopping, or summarizing research
Custom enterprise agents: navigating internal systems and surfacing strategic insights

These agents are not just passive conduits of information—they actively browse the web, evaluate options, and make decisions based on real-time data.

From “Searching” to “Delegating”

In a traditional search engine experience, users input a query, browse results, and decide which links to click.

With Agentic AI, the user simply states a goal—like “Find the best property management software and set up a demo”—and the agent handles the entire process.

This eliminates multiple steps of user interaction and bypasses standard SERP behavior.

It also removes another middle-man that is frequently used by SEO agencies: the virtual assistant.

How AI Agents Interact With the Web

Rather than being guided by snippets and titles in search results, agentic AI systems:

Scrape content for factual data from various web sources
Query APIs and structured datasets from existing and new sources
Prioritize trusted, verified sources (think EEAT for Google, but with real “learning” involved)
Analyze readability, clarity, and actionability—not just keyword relevance or the anchor text of a backlink

In short, AI agents don’t behave like humans—and that has profound implications for how websites should be structured and optimized.

How Agentic AI is Changing the Search Landscape

The rise of Agentic AI represents a shift from search as a human-driven discovery process to search as an autonomous task completed by machines.

This search transition is already reshaping the digital ecosystem in several key ways.

1. Decline in Traditional Search Queries

As more users delegate tasks to AI agents, we’re seeing a decline in traditional keyword-based queries. Instead of typing “best CRM software for small business,” users might prompt their AI to “find and sign me up for the best-rated CRM that integrates with Gmail and is under $100/month.” The AI might never display a SERP—it simply performs the task.

2. Rise of Zero-Click and AI-Generated Answers

Google and other platforms have already been moving toward zero-click searches, where answers are displayed directly on the page without requiring a click. Agentic AI accelerates this trend by consuming and summarizing content internally, often never exposing the original source to the end user.

In short, search engines still use your content to created the AI-generated answers, but users are much less likely to click away and visit your site unless they really want to know and dive deeper.

3. Direct-to-Answer Systems

With models like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini, and Anthropic’s Claude, answers are generated on the fly by aggregating knowledge from multiple sources.

In many cases, the user doesn’t know (or care) where the data comes from—so long as it’s accurate and helpful.

4. AI Agents Don’t Click—They Act

Unlike a human who might click several links, skim through a few articles, and compare options, AI agents:

Scrape content directly
Evaluate data based on instructions or goals
Make choices algorithmically based on structure, clarity, and authority

This means the traditional SEO tactics designed to attract human clicks—like compelling headlines or rich snippets—may not apply in the same way.

The new SEO is less about visibility on a page and more about being useful and machine-readable.

And, if your brand wants to stand out in this new world, you need to:

Actually have a brand. That is, you need to be recognizable as a name or company that people recognize.
Be omnichannel. Your content needs to be ever-present and in-your-face. That means not just blogs, but YouTube, podcasts and social media to build awareness.

SEO in the Age of AI Agents

As AI agents become the new intermediaries between users and information, SEO must adapt from a human-centric model to one that is equally (if not more) optimized for machines. This shift calls for a rethinking of how content is created, structured, and surfaced.

1. Content Must Be Machine-Readable First
Agentic AI systems consume information differently from humans. They prioritize content that is:

Structured (clear hierarchy, headings, lists, tables)
Explicit (no fluff, minimal ambiguity)
Standardized (uses formats machines can parse easily)

This means content optimized for agents should rely heavily on:

Schema markup (e.g., JSON-LD)
Open APIs or machine-readable feeds
Clean HTML without excessive dynamic loading or obfuscation

2. Trust Signals Are More Important Than Ever
Agents rely on heuristics to determine which sources to trust. This reinforces the importance of Google’s E-E-A-T guidelines:

Experience – Demonstrated, real-world application
Expertise – Authorship from subject matter experts
Authoritativeness – Recognized by others in the field
Trustworthiness – Secure, accurate, and transparent

These signals aren’t just for Google anymore—they’re becoming baseline requirements for agentic systems to validate and act on content.

3. Optimizing for Agents ≠ Optimizing for Humans
Agents are less concerned with aesthetics and more concerned with logic, structure, and consistency. This means:

SEO must prioritize semantic clarity over clever copy
Metadata and technical SEO play a larger role than ever
Internal linking and topic modeling need to be precise and machine-navigable

4. AI Agents Prefer Actionable, Goal-Oriented Content
If an agent is tasked with “booking a vacation,” it will look for content that includes:

Clear pricing
Available dates
Booking URLs
Refund policies
Rather than a blog post on “Top 10 Vacation Spots,” the agent is more likely to engage with a structured booking platform or itinerary builder.

How to Still Use Humans When Agentic AI Dominates

In a digital world dominated by bots and agents, human interactions, leads and sales are still the end goal for most businesses and the bots still need to be run by human guidance.

Agencies have a responsibility to be at the forefront of the new agentic AI SEO industry; they should know the latest trends and best practices about search engine results pages & search results. Because of this, it’s best for agencies to complete the main SEO tasks that are mostly behind the scenes. These include:

Let Humans Drive the Overall AI Strategy

SEO agencies have the responsibility of designing the overall online marketing strategy of their clients, and then guiding the execution of it. This includes keyword research, google search console, google analytics, paid search, local search, search engine marketing, Voice search, competitive analysis, and content strategy.

As agentic AI continues to shape the way users find and act on information, SEO professionals and content creators must adopt new strategies to remain competitive in this evolving landscape.

Embrace Structured Data Everywhere

Structured data is no longer optional. To be visible (and actionable) to AI agents, your website should:

Implement comprehensive schema.org markup (products, reviews, FAQs, etc.)
Use JSON-LD format where possible for clarity
Include structured tables and bullet-point summaries for key info

Agents crawl and parse this data more efficiently than unstructured prose.

SEO Link Building

While not the end-all-be-all it once was, backlinks still have a piece in the overall algorithm for ranking in traditional SERPs and in AI overviews.

Local SEO citations, directory submissions, and other types of SEO link building are best left to SEO agencies because they generally already (should) have the processes in place, and understand the nuances of proper anchor text distribution, link type diversity, and domain diversity.

Agentic AI can help enhance this process and make it more efficient, but humans help lead the charge on the end goal.

Build and Expose APIs

If your site or service provides data, consider making it available through an open or authenticated API. Agentic systems often favor data they can pull directly and dynamically via endpoints. This is especially relevant for:

Real estate listings
Product catalogs
Market research data
Availability feeds (e.g. inventory, calendar bookings)

SEO Audits

Website SEO audits are one of the first steps agencies should take for clients who already have an online presence.

The purpose of the audit is to identify and understand what the business is doing right, as well as what needs to be improved.

SEO audits become more important as search becomes infinitely more complex.

Create Actionable, Transaction-Ready Content

Make your content not just informative, but executable. Pages should include:

Clear CTAs
Direct links to conversion points (buy, book, apply)
Explicit next steps or decision trees
Linkbait: Content with the potential to go viral, like infographics, are best for SEO agencies, since it’s unusual for clients to have a designer on staff. Furthermore, agencies typically have experience designing infographics that have the potential to go viral. They also usually already have designers on hand to design the infographic, along with the connections and resources to promote and distribute it.

Remember: AI agents are not browsing—they’re completing objectives. Help them help you.

Social Signals and Ominichannel Targeting

Social media marketing services aren’t offered by everyone, but because search engines algorithms are giving more and more weight to social signals for search results, the importance of a strong social media campaign is higher than ever.

As a result, agencies are offering community management, tweeting, Facebooking, and more on behalf of their clients to streamline marketing goals.

The right SEO agency (particularly, the right social media account manager) can make a world of difference here by focusing on content that is outside traditional text.

People are more likely to find your brand on Linkedin, Facebook and YouTube. Ignoring these channels may cause you to miss a great deal of opportunity for scaling.

Optimize for Source Attribution in AI Summaries

Even if your site doesn’t get clicked, being cited or summarized by AI can still deliver brand value. To improve attribution:

Use branded language and internal citations
Add author bylines and bios
Claim and verify your brand across trusted data sources (e.g., Wikidata, LinkedIn, Crunchbase)

Prioritize Speed, Security & Clarity

Agents favor fast, secure, and clear experiences. Make sure your site:

Loads quickly (especially for mobile)
Is HTTPS-secured
Avoids intrusive popups, cookie modals, or login gates on key pages

Consider Training Your Own AI Agent

Forward-looking brands are beginning to train their own agentic tools based on internal data. If your business has proprietary knowledge or structured content, you might benefit from creating:

A domain-specific chatbot or AI assistant
A plugin for platforms like ChatGPT or Gemini
An internal search agent for employees or clients

Luckily, with the help of our DEV team, this helping to create your own custom, complex agent, is something we can help with.

The Future of SEO = Human + Machine Synergy!

While the rise of Agentic AI might seem like a threat to traditional SEO, it actually opens the door to a new, more collaborative era—one where human creativity and machine intelligence work in tandem to serve users more effectively than ever before.

SEO Isn’t Dying — It’s Evolving
Just as SEO evolved from keyword-stuffing to content marketing, it’s now transforming into something deeper: experience engineering.

The job isn’t just to rank on Google—it’s to create digital ecosystems that serve both human readers and AI agents seamlessly.

Human Creativity Still Matters
AI can execute and analyze, but it lacks emotional nuance, narrative flair, and original insight.

Content that resonates, inspires, and converts will still come from human minds.

The role of the SEO strategist becomes more like a systems architect—designing content and experiences that plug into both human desires and machine logic.

Collaboration Will Be Key
Future SEO teams will include:

Writers and strategists
AI prompt engineers
Data scientists
Developers building custom agents and tools

Together, they’ll build environments that communicate with users and machines—balancing clarity, persuasion, structure, and technical precision.

Multi-Channel Visibility Will Matter More Than Rankings
In a world where users get answers from AI assistants, visibility won’t just come from ranking #1 on a SERP. It will come from:

Being cited in AI-generated summaries
Having structured data pulled into agent workflows
Being accessible via APIs or third-party tools
Appearing in voice interfaces, app integrations, and agent dashboards

The brands that adapt to this new distribution model will outpace those stuck optimizing solely for Google’s SERPs.

Author
Recent Posts

Nate Nead

Nate Nead is the Owner of SEO.co, an SEO agency that has served some of the most well-recognized online brands since 2010. Nate has personally helped the likes of Qualtrics, Box.com and GoDaddy improve their online rankings with his expert team of SEO gurus. Formerly licensed as an investment banker, Nate holds an MBA in Finance and Marketing from the University of Washington and an undergrad in Business from Brigham Young University.

Free Automated SEO Site Audit