For years, keyword rankings were the lifeblood of SEO.
Digital agencies built entire reporting models around tracking specific phrases and their positions in Google.
Clients obsessed over being “number one” for their primary keywords.
Ranking reports were considered gospel — proof that SEO was “working.”
But the world has changed.
Artificial intelligence is reshaping the search landscape in ways that are fundamentally undermining the importance of keyword rankings.
What once served as a meaningful metric is now little more than a vanity exercise — and in some cases, dangerously misleading.
It’s time to retire keyword rankings as a primary SEO KPI.
Table of Contents
The Historical Obsession with Keyword Rankings
To understand how we got here, it helps to remember why keyword rankings mattered in the first place.
For years, Google operated on a fairly static model: 10 blue links on a search results page, ranked in a clear hierarchy. If you ranked #1 for “personal injury lawyer Chicago,” you could expect a steady stream of highly qualified traffic. Rankings correlated closely with impressions, clicks, and leads.
Naturally, SEO clients wanted to know:
-
Where do we rank?
-
Are we moving up?
-
How do we compare to competitors?
SEO agencies responded by building rank-tracking into their core service models.
Entire businesses were built around selling ranking improvements.
And for a while, that made sense.
Enter AI: The Death of Linear Rankings
Then artificial intelligence arrived.
With the rollout of AI-powered search engines — Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE), Bing Copilot, Perplexity, ChatGPT web browsing, and others — the linear structure of search results has started to dissolve.
Instead of serving everyone the same list of links, AI engines deliver synthesized, personalized answers drawn from multiple sources.
And they are getting better at knowing what you want, feeding you content in a vacuum based on your previous queries.
The result you see may differ dramatically from the result I see, depending on factors like:
-
Search history — how often users visit and what they are doing when they are on your website can tell a lot about how they feel about your business and brand
-
Location — Are your visitors coming from Russia and India or are they primarily in the United States?
-
Device (desktop vs. mobile vs. tablet)
-
Real-time data sources
-
User intent — and where the user sits in the marketing funnel
Even Google’s traditional search results are now filled with featured snippets, knowledge panels, People Also Ask boxes, AI summaries, local packs and now “AI Mode” that push traditional rankings further down the page.
In many cases, users no longer even see the “organic rankings” that agencies have spent years tracking.
Why Chasing Rankings is Now Largely Pointless
The traditional rank tracking model simply can’t keep up with the way AI search works today.
-
Rankings are highly fluid. What you see may not reflect what your customer sees.
-
AI-generated summaries answer questions without clicks. Many users get what they need directly from an AI response, without ever clicking through to a website.
-
Multiple SERP features dominate above-the-fold real estate. Even a #1 organic ranking may sit far below AI-generated content and other search features.
-
Personalized SERPs mean fragmented data. Rankings (and traffic) depend on variables outside of your control. And those variables grow infinitely when users perform multiple follow-up searches to an initial query.
At best, keyword rankings have become a loose directional signal.
At worst, they give businesses a false sense of progress while failing to capture whether SEO efforts are driving real business outcomes.
Keyword Rankings: The Ultimate Vanity Metric
Vanity metrics are those that look good on paper but fail to provide actionable insight or correlate with business performance.
Keyword rankings increasingly fall into this category:
-
They don’t reflect real user behavior.
-
They don’t capture traffic quality.
-
They don’t measure conversions.
-
They don’t account for AI-driven zero-click outcomes.
Clients love seeing their target keywords sitting pretty on a report.
But that doesn’t mean those rankings are generating leads, sales, or revenue.
What Metrics Actually Matter in 2025 and Beyond
If keyword rankings are no longer reliable, where should businesses focus instead?
Here’s where we advise our clients at SEO.co to shift their attention:
-
Organic Traffic Trends: Total search traffic, accounting for all keywords and long-tail variations. More importantly, are you trending up in your “overall” keyword rankings? Is your traffic on the incline or the decline?
-
Conversion Data: Leads, sales, and revenue attributable to organic search. THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT METRIC!
-
Brand Visibility in AI Outputs: Is your brand being cited or summarized in AI-generated answers?
-
Entity-Based Optimization: Are your brand and key topics recognized in Google’s Knowledge Graph and LLM training data? Do you have the right semantic and entity keywords mixed in your body content to disambiguate what your page is about?
-
Backlink Authority: High-quality, earned backlinks still matter as signals of trust. But, the other ranking factors are increasing in overall “weight” in AI SEO.
-
Topical Authority Signals: Depth and breadth of content coverage across your niche.
-
Engagement Metrics: Click-through-rates, time on site, bounce rates, page depth — indicators of real user interest in your content and your brand.
The common theme: real-world business outcomes, not superficial rankings.
The New SEO Playbook for the AI Era
AI isn’t killing SEO — but it is changing how SEO must be approached.
Winning in AI-powered search requires:
-
Building Topical Authority: Comprehensive, expert-level content that answers questions thoroughly.
-
Optimizing Entities, Not Just Keywords: Become a recognized authority tied to specific topics, brands, and people.
-
Leveraging Structured Data & Schema: Feed AI engines the context they need to understand and surface your content.
-
Earning Mentions, Not Just Links: PR, citations, interviews, and social signals that position your brand as an expert.
-
Focusing on Brand Building: Long-term authority that transcends individual keyword phrases.
This is a shift from transactional SEO to strategic SEO — from chasing individual rankings to building defensible authority.
What SEOs and Clients Need to Do Now
If you’re still sending keyword ranking reports to your clients, it’s time to stop.
Clients don’t need keyword rankings. They need revenue growth. They need qualified leads. They need measurable ROI from their digital marketing spend.
At SEO.co, we help clients navigate this shift by:
-
Eliminating keyword ranking reports from core deliverables. If you really want them, you don’t need an SEO agency to track them for you. There are plenty of tools for this.
-
Providing business-focused reporting tied to real KPIs like “qualified” leads captured (first determine what qualified means), sales generated, revenue growth and reduced churn.
-
Helping brands position themselves as authoritative entities in the eyes of both users and AI systems. This still includes things like Digital PR, technical SEO and even link building services.
-
Building durable SEO strategies that will survive — and thrive — in the AI search revolution. In other words, in means establishing a brand that is recognizable offline and well as online. No more one-trick-pony marketing strategies.
Conclusion
AI is not just changing the search results — it’s changing the way we measure success in SEO.
Keyword rankings, once the holy grail, are rapidly becoming irrelevant.
In an AI-driven world, vanity metrics won’t drive business growth. Authority, trust, visibility, and brand equity will.
The sooner businesses embrace this reality, the more prepared they’ll be for the future of search.
If you’re ready to build a future-proof SEO strategy that goes beyond vanity metrics, reach out to SEO.co — we’re here to help.
- Pros and Cons of Done-For-You SEO Services - June 5, 2025
- Thanks to AI, Keyword Rankings are Now Vanity Metrics - June 3, 2025
- Google Doesn’t Owe You Anything - May 26, 2025
