Link building is a double-edged sword.
Some backlinks help.
And, because authority is measured logarithmically, some backlinks REALLY help.
Unfortunately, some backlinks hurt.
The worst backlinks can be very detrimental.
Not all link building strategies are effective. It can be tough to tell whether the time and money you spend on link building services is truly paying off.
When it comes to performing a complete audit or backlink profile analysis, most webmasters take a reactive vs. proactive approach.
But monitoring your backlinks and referring domains with regular manual and software-based backlink audits is critical in today’s ever-changing world of search algorithm updates, particularly if you don’t want toxic links to harm your organic traffic from search engines.
Here we outline the process for backlink profile analysis with regular backlink auditing.
Let’s dive in.
Table of Contents
What Is a Backlink Audit Analysis?
Depending on the nature of your site and how much effort you’ve put into building links, there are probably hundreds to thousands of links and various referring domains linking to the various pages of your site.
Maybe you were referenced in a press release or noted as a sponsor for a charity event, or maybe you were featured in a series of offsite articles.
The sum total of these backlinks, as they exist today, is your backlink profile (linkgraph or, simply, link profile).
A backlink audit, then, is the art of studying and evaluating your (or your competitors’) link profile.
There are many ways to use this in your favor; for example, you can use it to track how far your reach has grown over a period of time, including how many new publishers you’ve been featured on.
You can use it to spot and correct mistakes. Perhaps most importantly, you can tie factors like the quantity or quality of links you’ve built to the results you’re seeing on your website.
You can also use link profile audit & analysis as a means of competitive analysis.
Instead of auditing your own backlink profile, you can look at the profiles of your closest competitors to examine differences between your approaches, or gain inspiration for new strategies.
Backlink Audit Tools
Before we get into specifics on what your link profile audit entails and what your linkgraph should look like, you should know how to view and analyze your profile itself.
The depth of backlink data available in Google Search Console is limited (likely because Google wants to avoid incentivizing link schemes or simply just to maintain their control over proprietary data)
You may keep track of the links and referring domains you’ve built manually, but this won’t tell you any information on referring domains you’ve naturally attracted, which are even more important.
Two of the very best tools to use for analyzing your site’s backlinks include:
- Ahrefs and
- Moz’s Link Explorer.
- Google Search Console
Both tools allow you to search for any domain and see a breakdown of:
- how that domain is performing, including an estimation of your domain authority (which can help you track the authority of your site over time) or domain rating (in the case of Ahrefs)
- the number of both referring domains and inbound links that are currently pointing to your site and the corresponding anchor text
- the number of different referring domains that have links pointing to your site
- the total number of internal links on your site and the anchor text used
- the number of keywords for which your site ranks
- mix of nofollow links versus dofollow links as websites link naturally using both
- how many links you’ve gained or lost over a specific period of time
There are other tools available to audit and evaluate your link profile, but so long as they provide you with accurate information, the differences come down to UI, so your choice should be based on personal preferences.
Every tool on the market has its pros and cons.
We have found detrimental links through Moz that were invisible to Ahrefs backlink lookups, so having the complete picture with both tools is helpful.
The Ideal Backlink Profile
As an evaluative tool, your backlink profile’s main function is to help you measure how far you are from the ideal, and whether your efforts are being translated into measurable results.
If you’re not seeing results, you can dig deeper into your link specifics to see which areas are lacking.
Even if you’re seeing moderately good results, you can identify key areas for improvement, based on whether they adhere to “ideal” standards.
So what are these “ideal” standards? You should be able to judge a backlink profile on the following dimensions, and reasonably determine whether it’s going to be effective in building your search engine rankings:
Link quantity
Anyone active in the link building or SEO community knows that there’s a danger in excessively linking to your site. If you build too many links or build them too quickly, it will look suspicious, and you could face a penalty. That said, link quantity does play a role in how your site’s trustworthiness is evaluated. Essentially, the more links (and especially the more referring domains) you have pointing to you, the more trustworthy it’s going to seem (so long as you meet a number of other important conditions, which we’ll cover momentarily).
Accordingly, it’s good to keep a close eye on the number of backlinks in your profile.
This will help you ensure that you’re executing on your goals, like if you have a target of publishing 10 new links a month from different referring domains, but will also help you notice and evaluate links that come to you naturally.
Perhaps even more importantly, finding a deviation in your link numbers can clue you into a problem with your strategy, such as a publisher removing your links from publication.
Link quantity also matters for your individual pages, since you’ll need to focus on both domain authority and page authority.
For a general strategy, you’ll want to build links pointing to a variety of internal pages, but if there’s a specific landing page or a specific piece of content you want to emphasize, you may want a disproportionate number of links pointing to it.
Linking Domain and Page Authority
You’ll also need to pay attention to the domain authority, or DA, of the referring domains pointing to you. In general, the higher the DA, the more valuable the link is going to be. One strong link from a high-authority source could potentially be more valuable than dozens of links from low-quality sources.
Many dofollow backlinks with similar domain authority can have a huge impact on your rankings in search engines.
By that same token, you should keep an eye out for such links from low-quality or questionable sources.
If Google notices one or more such links from a source that could be considered spammy links, it could diminish your domain authority and hurt you more than help you.
Hopefully, you aren’t actively seeking these low-authority sources, like article directories and shady forums, but it’s still possible that a link to your site could show up there.
Performing a backlink audit in this dimension can help you remove spammy backlinks from questionable sources; to do this, usually all you have to do is send an email to the webmaster (though in some rare cases, you may need to disavow the link through Google Search Console).
You can also determine whether your spammy links (and even paid links) could be considered toxic links that may warrant your further review and potential removal.
In fact, in the past we operated link removal services, but in today’s world Google ignores or wholly deindexes most spam links.
Linking domain relevance
Each domain linking to your site should have some kind of relevance to that site, either due to the purpose of the domain or because of the topic of the article. This isn’t a strict necessity, but you should consider it as a general rule. For example, if you run an ice cream parlor, but all your links are coming from auto manufacturers, it could raise suspicions that you’re receiving your links illegitimately, or that your links aren’t providing value to the people encountering them.
This can alert you to any sites that are linking to your pages nefariously or without link quality in mind. It is also another sign to search engines of spammy links.
Again, it’s a good trigger to reach out and remove them.
Otherwise, this can help you stay on track with your goals by giving you a bird’s-eye view on the relevance of your linking domains.
Linking domain diversity
Even quality free backlinks have diminishing returns when they exist on the same domain. The first time you earn a link to your site on a domain, you’ll get tons of authority (and value) from it. The second link you earn will still have a measurable impact, but it will be significantly less so than your first. After building multiple links on a single domain, you’ll stop getting authority benefits from new links, incentivizing you to seek out newer domains. For similar reasons, if it looks like your domain is consistently “swapping” links with another partner domain, it could render both efforts counterproductive.
Ideally, you’ll get links from a diversity of different sources (including both dofollow links and nofollow links), and your backlink analysis will inform you how close you are to that goal.
If you notice lots of links from the same source or series of sources, it should motivate you to branch out.
That said, it’s worth noting that even if you aren’t getting authority benefits from inbound links on certain domains, they can still be valuable to you, earning you referral traffic and brand exposure.
Keep these secondary effects in mind
Branded and keyword-based anchor text
Despite getting nerfed by the Hummingbird update and Google’s increasing focus on semantic search, keywords are still an important part of SEO. In addition to playing a massive role in your onsite optimization strategy, your keyword choices in your links’ anchor text can influence your site’s relevance and rankings in search engines.
A backlink audit is the perfect opportunity to evaluate which keyword terms you’re using, and how much brand exposure you’re getting in that anchor text.
Generally speaking, anchor text that features your brand name (or a variable of your brand name, like a product name, abbreviation, or nickname) is more valuable than other kinds of anchor text.
You can also use keywords in your anchor text to improve your relevance for search queries that include or are similar to those keywords.
Chances are, if you’re planning a keyword and/or link building strategy, you’re already orchestrating your keywords intentionally.
Still, observing your anchor text patterns is valuable in a backlink audit because you’ll see what types of keywords or brand-related terms are being used in natural backlinks, and you can see whether certain types of anchored links are being removed.
Relevant anchor text
Even though including strategic keyword terms can be valuable for your ranking strategy, you still need to consider their relevance. For a truly strong link, the anchor text of that link need to be semantically relevant both to the article it’s linking to and to the article in which it’s included.
For example, if you’re writing an article about roof repair and you’re linking to your law firm’s homepage, the anchor text “repair a roof” might be relevant to the core article, but won’t be relevant to your law firm.
The anchor text “contact an attorney” might be relevant to your home page, but won’t be as relevant to the core article.
Your anchor text relevance doesn’t need to be perfect, but you should examine the patterns of anchor text you use and make note of trends of irrelevance.
The more semantically natural and appropriate the anchor text is, the better it’s going to be for the integrity of your link.
Anchor text diversity
Your backlink audit is also a good time to check your anchor text diversity. If you use the same anchor text over and over again, Google’s algorithm is going to catch it—and you could end up with a penalty as a result. Too many link builders get fixated on a single keyword or phrase, and use that as the anchor text for every link they build, regardless of the article housing that link or the nature of the domain. This is bad practice, and should be avoided at all costs.
If you notice too many instances of the same anchor text, but you still want to target the same keywords, you can experiment with synonyms and different phrasings to achieve a similar result.
After all, Google takes synonyms and similar phrases into account when populating results.
Link destination diversity
Even if you’re trying to push for one key page on your website (like a landing page for a product or a piece of content you’re particularly proud of), it’s still a good idea to feature a diversity of links in your backlink profile. Building links to many internal pages from a lot of relevant referring domains, as well as your homepage, will make your link profile seem more natural, and give you more page authority throughout your site.
Again, your strategy may already specify which pages you want to target, but your backlink audit is a good opportunity to evaluate how you’re doing (and potentially make adjustments).
As you add more valuable content to your site, you can work it into your rotation and ensure there are always new destinations to target.
Link velocity
The speed with which you acquire links over a given period of time, can have a major impact on the relevance of your ranking. Building links is great, but a natural linkgraph typically includes a build-up and not a cavalcade of backlinks over short periods. We discuss link velocity in detail here.
The following graphs from Ahrefs show better than I could tell:
And the subsequent recovery from the decline, which took almost a year:
Yes, the recovery took time, but in the absence of backlink monitoring, the recognition of a problem in the link profile and the subsequent recovery would have been unnecessarily extended.
And, revenue would have suffered for longer than necessary.
Link history
Finally, you’ll want to pay attention to the overall history and integrity of your links. Monitoring your link profile is the best way to see whether your links remain up for an extended period of time; if an abnormal number of your links end up being removed, it could be a sign that the quality of your content is lacking, or that you aren’t targeting the right publishers. Ideally, you’ll want most of your links to last for years.
Google also wants to see fresh links, not all redirects from some PBN built on expired domains. If all your links are from several years ago, with minimal recent links, or if your new links come in massive spurts (rather than being built iteratively), it could be a bad sign.
Make sure you have plenty of new inbound links to keep your link profile modern and relevant—though if you’re already working on your link profile analysis, you’re probably investing in new links regularly.
These are the areas you should bear in mind when evaluating your current links, at least in terms of authority and SEO contributions.
However, as briefly referenced above, links have more than just authority or SEO value.
When evaluating the overall effectiveness of your link building strategy, you should keep in mind other, secondary benefits, like brand exposure, thought leadership demonstration, referral traffic, and earning you future publication opportunities.
Because some of these factors are difficult to measure, you may not be able to objectively assess them during your backlink audit.
Competitive Backlink Monitoring
If you’re interested in evaluating your competition’s backlink profiles, keep an eye out for the following:
Missed opportunities
Are there domains or publishers where your competitor is frequently mentioned, but you have no real presence? These could be missed opportunities. The fact that your competitor is using them frequently means they’re either highly accessible or they’re extremely valuable (or both). They’re worth considering if you’re looking for new ways to distribute or promote your content.
Brand differentiation
This is also a chance to find unique ways to differentiate your brand. Look for patterns in the types of publishers, how websites links to them and keywords your competitor is targeting. Is there a key demographic they’re overlooking? Is there a keyword niche they aren’t taking advantage of? If you swoop in and take over that niche, there may be nobody else to compete with.
Keywords and strategic insights
Once you get experienced in backlink audit, it will be easy to see the hallmarks of a focused strategy; you’ll notice specifically phrased anchor text, similarities in posting titles and publishers, and a rhythm to the posting schedule and/or publication frequency of their work. If there isn’t much competition vying for the same online space, it should signal you to kick your strategy into higher gear; after all, nobody’s going to stand in your way. Otherwise, you can get a feel for what types of strategies they’re using, specifically, and craft a strategy that can complement it.
Link Profile Monitoring Habits
Consistency is key if you want your backlink audit to be effective.
You can start by committing to a regular schedule; at periodic intervals, you should be checking your progress, keeping an eye on your domain authority and number of inbound links.
If and when those results deviate from your expectations, or on a defined rotation, you can dig into the “meat” of your backlink profile, identifying lost links, inconsistencies, mistakes, or potential areas of improvement.
The exact timing here depends on your brand and your goals.
For example, if you’re managing links for a large company and you have significant competitors and a high volume of outgoing content, you should be checking your link profile at least a few times a week, and doing a deep dive once a week.
For smaller businesses just getting their feet wet in SEO, a monthly deep dive may be plenty.
Backlink monitoring also shouldn’t be your only mode of evaluation; for example, you’ll need to study the patterns in your referral traffic closely if you want a better understanding of how your strategy is panning out, and evaluate other elements of your strategy (such as onsite optimization) if and when you notice deviations from your expectations.
Your link profile, while important, is only one piece of the bigger puzzle of SEO analysis.
Making Actionable Changes to Your Link Building Strategy
The insights you glean while studying your link profile aren’t going to mean much unless they lead to real, actionable changes in your link building strategy.
For example, if you lose a link, the knowledge might help you find peace with the fact that your domain authority is taking a hit, but it isn’t going to restore or replace that link.
And if you notice you aren’t accumulating a diversity of linking domains as quickly as you intended, that knowledge is only going to benefit you if you change your approach.
Accordingly, the best way to structure a link profile analysis is to summarize it with action-focused takeaways.
Instead of making a bullet point that “anchor text lacks diversity,” make a memo to come up with new keyword targets and/or phrases, and designate a point person to be accountable for seeing the change through to fruition.
From there, check in regularly to make sure you’re following and/or achieving those action items.
Alternatively, you could work with a link building agency to make sure you’re building natural links for organic traffic and SEO as efficiently as possible.
If you’re ready to conduct a comprehensive SEO audit on your site, or if your link building strategy is in need of an overhaul, contact us today!
Don’t do your complete link audit and backlink profile analysis without first checking out our free backlink checker tool!
We’ll work with you in your link building efforts and can get your brand featured in the best publications out there—and your link profile will look better than it ever has before.
Over the years he's written for publications like Forbes, Entrepreneur, Marketing Land, Search Engine Journal, ReadWrite and other highly respected online publications. Connect with Tim on Linkedin & Twitter.
- 14 Ideas for Local SEO Content - September 18, 2023
- Link Building for Local SEO: How to Build Backlinks for Local SEO - September 7, 2023
- Navigation Links Best Practices for SEO - September 5, 2023
